It is a truth (kind of) universally acknowledged (okay, only psychology textbooks acknowledge it) that every individual walks around looking at other folks’ lives assuming he, himself, could be managing that life much better.
Aren’t the solutions to other people’s problems so simple?
One of the most obvious arenas for this mindset is the realm of parenting. Most people assume they are good parents. I was at a party one time and this guy’s kid came downstairs and the dude said, “If you do not get back upstairs right now, I will punch you in the face,” and his kid flew back upstairs as though The very Devil was on his trail. And that dad probably thinks he’s a good parent.
And who am I to say he isn’t? Clearly, I don’t know what I’m doing. I’ve read about eleventy million different parenting books, seen therapists, had innumerable parent/teacher/principal conferences, and I still wake up every goddam day dreading whatever choice I will have to make first.
As most of you know, my oldest child has Asperger’s Syndrome. I have struggled with that diagnosis and what it means, but when you get down to how I’ve dealt with it: I got pregnant at 21, was shotgun wed (how much of a choice I had is, in reality, quite debatable) and then, right out of the gate, had huge challenges. We had broken collarbones from the delivery, we had an unusual tongue situation that rendered my child almost completely unable to drink for his first four months (no, seriously.) and then we had what I only knew were ‘difficulties’ until I heard the words “Asperger’s Syndrome” for the first time in my life, from my son’s first grade teacher.
We thought knowing what was wrong would help us deal with it, but that’s a laugh. Yet we did not give up. The boy is crazy smart. This HAD to be a workable situation. So I read everything I could. I read all the books. I don’t just mean, “yeah, I’ve read all them books” I mean that I must have read every book ever written, in fact, every book in all of reality, in this dimension and others.
As a culmination of my studies, I am here to tell you what appears to be the number one piece parenting advice in existence. Are you ready for it? It’s heavy stuff. See, what you should be doing is…….
Try something different.
Try something different?
Are you f***ing kidding me?
WHAT DO YOU THINK I HAVE BEEN DOING?
Honest to god, that is the worst advice any human could give any other human in any situation. What do you think would happen if you walked into, like, a cancer research lab and told all the scientists, “Hey, ya know, I was thinking……what y’all have been doing just hasn’t fixed anything. Have you ever tried–and I’m just throwing this out here–have you tried doing something different?”
What do you think the scientists have been doing staring into all those microscopes and test-tubes and crap for all these years? Do you think they’re mixing blue with yellow over and over and over again, wailing, “Aw, crap, it’s green again! What are we doing wrong, you guys?!”
One of my son’s therapists (a guy with no children, I noticed) suggested a parenting maneuver that is, for veterans, one of the most elementary, intuitive techniques. It was so not-new territory. But this guy thought he was giving me the Rosetta Stone or something and when I informed him, “that tactic has no effect on my child,” he acted like I was this terrible mom who stubbornly refuses to try. He snarkily responded, “Well, if you don’t want anything to change……”
Yeah, a**hole. I don’t WANT anything to change. THAT’S why I’m here.
I’m just opposed to doing the same thing over and over with no new result. (Please don’t start talking about insanity, anybody. We’ve all heard that cliche.)
So about two years ago, when my son was struggling with fourth grade despite all the medications, behavior modification attempts, teacher seminars, and whatever else benevolent spirits could muster, I was crying to my husband one evening yet again.
Now, of course coming home to the same person crying over the same thing every day must be quite trying. But let’s just be honest and point out that it was me who had the shorter end of the stick. So I think I deserved a little bit more than a usual blank stare day after day followed with one final outburst consisting of him throwing up his hands and yelling, “Why don’t you try something different?”
Then we had one of those moments when both parties knows a gauntlet has been thrown down and now only vigorous back-pedaling can stop an all-out duel. But if you know my husband, you know that he wouldn’t be caught dead back-pedaling. It’s not his nture. He defends to the very death. So after a long pause, I choked out……
Me: Something different?
Him: Yeah. Just…..not something you’ve already tried.
*More of tense pause*
Me: I understand the DEFINITION OF THE WORDS. I USED TO BE A HIGH SCHOOL ENGLISH TEACHER BEFORE I GAVE IT UP TO TAKE CARE OF OUR SPECIAL NEEDS CHILD.
Him: You know what I mean.
Me: DO I? DO I? If you mean I should ransack my brain to come up with yet a new program of behavior to try to coax some civility from him, I promise you, I’m all tapped out.
Him: (knowing there is nothing that would possibly be a smart thing to say)……
Me: You….You didn’t have some idea, did you?
Him: ……
Me: You’ve thought of something?
Him: No…….I just mean….
Me: That it’s my job to think of the something different? That’s what you mean, isn’t it?
So that went on for a while and did not end well. For the record, he never did come up with any “idea” other than the “idea” of “try something different”.
After six years of desperately working with my son to perform reasonably in school, I have realized two major things. 1) Public school is just not the right situation, and 2) Medication reliably does nothing but kill my son’s appetite so badly that I start crying every time I see the poor child without his shirt on.
Since I’m pretty much working solo most days and without a net, here, I made two executive decisions. 1) No more medication, and 2) Homeschool.
Do I have trepidation about these new situations? God, yes. I’d be crazy if I didn’t. However, I AM TRYING. I AM DOING SOMETHING DIFFERENT. Wouldn’t you think somebody–anybody–would have something encouraging to say about it? They could say, “Hey! You’re taking my awesome advice! That’s so great! It’s amazing that you’re trying something different!” They could say, “You’re such a devoted mom to make this sacrifice.” They could say, “It can’t possibly be worse than the last six years.” If they were feeling extremely magnanimous they could say something like, “You’re a good mom. A bad mom wouldn’t bother.”
It seems like the people who ought to typically be saying anything at all encouraging could come up with maybe one benign remark for me, instead of echoes of my own doubts and invalidations of my choices and criticisms of my “complaints”.
But who has? Who has had one loving word for me in any of this difficult path? Where is all my due accolade for taking all that super useful expert advice about trying something different?
Pouring my heart out to the internet is kind of a dead give-away, isn’t it?